|
Book Review:
Author: CPT
John O'Donnell-Rosales (AL)
This book is a
compilation of Confederate soldiers of Spanish ancestry. It is
a roster - a list of names designed to open the way to a
forgotten history. The author is a descendent of PVT Kelvin
Rosales of Louisiana, LA State Militia Reserves, who served
throughout what the Foreword calls the Second American
Revolution, and who surrendered with the last Confederate
units in June 1865. That preface says: "This study will
introduce the student to the sizeable contribution of the
Hispanic community to the Confederate military. [John
O'Donnell-] Rosales helps us see again that our beloved
Southland has not been monolithic in its people or physical
regions. It is hoped that others will gain from this work the
understanding that our Confederate heritage belongs not to one
race, religion, or ethnic group, but is a shared experience of
the whole people of the South."
The preface
includes insight into reasons for support of the Confederacy:
War for
Southern Independence caught these settlers and many other
businessmen, traders and sailors in a decisive situation.
Should they support their respective States and the newly
founded Confederate Government, or sit out the war as many
foreigners did exempt from military obligations due to foreign
nationality. The answer was to fight for their new found
homes. One then gets into the question of slavery, the answer
is simple, less than ten percent (10%) of Southerners owned
slaves.... The Hispanic Confederate was not fighting for the
right to keep ten percent (10%) of Southern Whites as slave
owners. ... The question is then, why? The answer, I believe,
is that they fought to maintain their way of life, and
afterwards when the South was invaded to protect their
families and homes. The concept of community and familial
obligations runs deep in the Spanish tradition. That this was
one of the reasons so many of these men joined the Confederate
Military, due to perceived sociological responsibility is also
a possibility that should be further researched. ...
Likewise, the rank
and file of Southern soldiers were not slave owners. For those
interested in the reasons why men fought in the Civil War,
there is a recent book, For Cause and Comrades, by
James M. McPherson, which goes into this subject in depth
[Oxford University Press (1997) $25.00.]
This concept of
various and diverse backgrounds and culture among Hispanics is
further recognized by service of those who we may assume were
Jews of the Sephardim. (These were Spanish all through the
Middle Ages, and even after being expelled from Spain in 1492
they maintained a separate culture from those of other
European backgrounds, Ashkenazi.)
Hispanic
Confederates is designed to open the way to a study of
Hispanic contribution to the Confederate military, a forgotten
history.
Hispanic
Confederates is copyrighted 1997 by the author and Rice
Mango Publications, Mobile, AL. Copies may be purchased direct
from the author, CPT John O'Donnell-Rosales, P. O. Box 667,
Mobile, AL 36606. ($19.95) |